Thursday, September 11, 2008

Brich Shmay - Ant Hu Shalit

ant hu shalit - yosele rosenblatt


Baruch Shemay-Yitzchok Helfgot - Cantors World

10 comments:

Shmuel said...

Please let me know what you think....

Peretz said...

about?

Shmuel said...

Its the same song. The first file is Rosenblatt, the second is Helfgot.

Who sings this piece better?

Shmuel said...

Its the same song. The first file is Rosenblatt, the second is Helfgot.

Who sings this piece better?

Peretz said...

so far, helfgot screwed up the first "umalchuso"...

sounds like he has something stuck in his throat

Avi said...

Uh, and the first "Shalit." Yossele has my vote.

Levi said...

I was there when he sang this in Dec 2003 at Lincoln Center.
On his latest cd, Itche Meir does it real smooth.
But then again Yossele takes the cake for composition and execution

Shmuel said...

We all know you were at Lincon Center in 2003; you still have the play bill :)

Levi said...

and the ticket stub

Anonymous said...

was recorded during a concert ? because if it is it makes sense why he sounds so bad .in a studio they have excellent equipment to make him sound better than he is.in reality although helfgot is a great chazzan with a superb voice he is still too screechy and thin .